English Language Feeds

California appeals court rules Deep Springs College may admit women

Inside Higher Ed - Mon, 04/17/2017 - 00:00

A California appeals court ruled 3 to 0 last week that Deep Springs College, the smallest college in the United States and one of the most rigorous, may admit women.

The board of Deep Springs voted in 2011 to end its policy of admitting only men. But litigation from some alumni opposed to admitting women has held up the admission of women -- even as the student body, faculty members and many alumni have strongly backed the switch.

Deep Springs is a two-year college in the high desert of California with an enrollment of 26 and an unusual curriculum and history. But the focus of the legal fight has been less on the merits of single-sex education than on an issue that affects many colleges of all types: the circumstances under which a trust that sets up a program may be changed.

The alumni who challenged coeducation have argued that L. L. Nunn, the industrialist and educational thinker who founded Deep Springs in 1917, wanted to educate only men. And there are references in the trust documents to a mission of educating men.

But the college's leaders have argued that the unique style of education is the true mission of the college, not educating only men. The college has admitted very small classes of highly intelligent men, who take intense courses while managing both the college and its farm. Students who complete the program are admitted as transfer students to some of the most competitive colleges in the country. All students receive a full scholarship.

There are only a few other all-male colleges (besides seminaries) left in the country: Hampden-Sydney, Morehouse and Wabash Colleges and Saint John's University in Minnesota. Morehouse and Saint John's have close relationships with adjacent women's colleges. All the all-male colleges, except Deep Springs, want to remain that way.

The California appeals court noted that Deep Springs has in fact already changed in ways that deviated from Nunn's original vision. For instance, Nunn promoted religious instruction, which was dropped early in the college's history. Further, while Nunn advocated that students should govern themselves in their dormitory, the college now involves students in managing all aspects of college operations, giving students a managerial role -- including oversight of admissions and participation in the hiring and oversight of faculty members and administrators -- that is far beyond what Nunn envisioned or the norm in higher education.

The key finding of the appeals court was that a lower court had been within its discretion to approve a change in the trust guidelines for the college from promoting "the education of promising young men" to "the education of promising young people." There was no evidence, the appeals court said, that the lower court had exceeded its authority to determine which trust provisions were "administrative" (such as the reference to men) and which ones were focused on the central mission of the college (the overall approach). The lower court also noted arguments that admitting women would help Deep Springs advance its mission in that some prospective students and faculty members (male and female alike) won't consider a single-sex institution.

It remains unclear if last week's ruling will end the litigation. Those challenging coeducation and their lawyers could not be reached for comment.

Dave Hitz, the chair of the Deep Springs board, sent this statement to those affiliated with the college: "I am happy to announce that the appeals court ruled in favor of coeducation at Deep Springs. All three justices agreed. What does this mean? Is the lawsuit done? That depends. Until May 23, 2017, the objectors have the right to petition the California Supreme Court for review. If they do, we don't know if the court will accept the case for consideration or not. Never trust predictions about the legal system. Delays are common. Decisions can be overturned. That said, the trustees remain hopeful. This ruling is an important step toward a coeducational Deep Springs."

Editorial Tags: AdmissionsCourt rulingsWomenImage Caption: Deep Springs CollegeIs this diversity newsletter?: Newsletter Order: 0Is this Career Advice newsletter?: 

Colleges announce commencement speakers

Inside Higher Ed - Mon, 04/17/2017 - 00:00
Editorial Tags: Commencement speakersIs this diversity newsletter?: Newsletter Order: 0Is this Career Advice newsletter?: 

ACE Launches Moving the Needle Campaign to Achieve Higher Education Leadership Gender Parity

American Council on Education - Sat, 04/15/2017 - 03:01
A new campaign that asks presidents of colleges, universities and related associations to commit to helping achieve the goal that by 2030, half of U.S. college and university chief executives are women.

Attacks on universities, scholars, students unabated

University World News Global Edition - Sat, 04/15/2017 - 02:32
Even as the international community is raising its voice against the killing of higher education professionals in Pakistan, the assassination of intellectuals and violent killing of students conti ...

Can Lessons Learned From Fighting Al Qaeda Apply to Higher Education?

William H. McRaven, a retired admiral in the U.S. Navy who is now chancellor of the University of Texas system, describes the value of a “team of teams” and the role of the university as a home for dissent.

India to deepen university and training collaboration

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 11:16
India has pledged to work with the Australian government, universities and vocational education trainers to establish themselves in India following the two-day visit to Delhi of a 130-strong deleg ...

Trump's denial triggers 500 marches for science globally

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 10:05
The world's first March for Science will be held on Saturday 22 April, led by a flagship event in Washington DC in the ...

Where every tertiary student is a potential data point

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:36
It's a little strange to hear students being referred to as "potential test subjects" by a college president. But when the college in question is online-only and enrols 80,000 students w ...

Amnesty condemns academic's arrest for insulting president

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:34
Ugandan university lecturer and activist Dr Stella Nyanzi has been arrested on charges of 'cyber harassment' and 'offensive communication' against the office of the president, a move that has been ...

New insight into what international students do next

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:32
Some 51% of international graduates remain in New Zealand five years after completing their qualification and some 39% remain after eight years, according to a Ministry of Education report publish ...

Two key universities suffer from lack of leadership

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:30
Two of Kenya's largest universities are suffering leadership crises after operating without permanent or substantive vice-chancellors for nearly a year - in contravention of the law.

The situa ...

Brand is key challenge for international recruitment

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:20
Brand awareness is the key challenge facing universities in recruiting international students, according to an audience poll of a global webinar on ...

High dropout rates - Technology to the rescue?

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:14
With a high proportion of university students in South Africa dropping out before graduation, many in their first year of study, higher education institutions are turning to technology in an attem ...

The value of PhDs has shifted but is still disputed

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:12
Doctoral education in Sweden took a radical step forward when it switched to a four-year study period and allowed published articles to replace a single thesis, but the value of the doctorate is s ...

Right time for Australia and India to engage on HE

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:08
In 2060, India will be the most populous country, and likely have the largest economy, in the world. Roughly 20 million young people turn 18 every year, and according to some estimates, India's mi ...

Higher education for refugees - A call for action

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:04
At a time when issues related to refugees and the integration of immigrants are becoming key policy questions across different countries and regions, the international community needs to focus on ...

To remain a gateway to work, universities must change

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:02
A tipping point is being reached in post-secondary education, particularly for traditional colleges and universities. This tipping point is taking place over an extended period of time and has bee ...

Why fewer international students could be good news

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 07:00
The international student enrollment bubble at US universities might be beginning to burst and that may not be bad news. According to ...

'Rolling Stone' settles with former university dean

University World News Global Edition - Fri, 04/14/2017 - 06:26
Rolling Stone has reached a confidential settlement with Nicole Eramo, a former University of Virginia associate dean who had sued the magazine alleging that it defamed her in a 2014 story ...